Barton McNeil's case continues to unfold as his legal team presses forward with efforts to overturn his conviction. In February 2024, a McLean County judge denied his request for a new trial, stating that the new evidence presented would likely be inadmissible.

Following this decision, McNeil's attorneys filed an appeal with the Fourth District Appellate Court to challenge the trial court's ruling. This appeal process is ongoing, with a decision expected in 2025.

As of now, McNeil remains incarcerated, serving a life sentence at Graham Correctional Center. His case remains a point of contention, with supporters arguing for his innocence and working to bring attention to his situation through various channels, including public advocacy and legal appeals. The outcome of his appeal could significantly affect his future, potentially leading to a new trial or the maintenance of his current sentence.